Study questions for a sequencing article:
What is the article citation? Include the full article title, a PubMed link to the article, and a link to the article's original publisher.
Who is the corresponding author and what is their institutional affiliation? The corresponding author is usually the last author on the author list. They will have an asterisk or another symbol by their name. This is the person who oversees the project and makes publication decisions.
What samples did the study use (tissue type and gestational age and source of sample)? Define any acronyms used. Some examples:
- Placenta - what gestational age? If pre-delivery, were the samples from terminations or from continuing pregnancies?
- Cord blood - this is collected at delivery. Were the pregnancies "full term" or "pre-term" or otherwise described?
- Plasma - when collected?
- Serum - when collected?
Did they collect the samples themselves? If they are analyzing data from another paper, what is the citation for that other study? Check methods to see if they indicate an NCBI GEO accession ID (begins with "GSE").
What sequencing or array method(s) did they use? Some examples:
- total RNA-sequencing: sequences all RNAs after depletion of ribosomal RNAs.
- mRNA-sequencing: only sequences the polyadenylated RNAs (with polyA tails) using oligo(dT) primers or probes during the library preparation.
- miRNA-sequencing, microRNA-sequencing, or small RNA-sequencing: sequences small RNAs within a specific size range.
- ATAC-sequencing: sequencing to identify accessible chromatin regions, where DNA is available for protein binding. This is used to find regulatory DNA regions and identify how genes might be controlled.
- Bisulfite sequencing: a sequencing-based method to measure DNA methylation
- DNA methylation array: an array-based method to measure DNA methylation, but which one? The two most common arrays are the 450k array (older) and the EPIC array (twice the size at 860k sites). Some papers also use custom arrays.
- Vocabulary to help distinguish methods:
- "Total RNA" = all RNA isolated from the sample before any depletion or enrichment step. The use of the term "total RNA" does not indicate the sequencing method. Most RNA in cells is actually ribosomal RNA so pre-sequencing steps usually include a negative selection (remove rRNA) or a positive selection (pick up only polyA-tail RNA).
- Library preparation is the step to convert RNA into cDNA before RNA-sequencing. The cDNA "library" is what is actually sequenced.
- DNA is bisulfite converted for methylation arrays also, so the word "bisulfite" in methods does not by itself indicate bisulfite sequencing.